Alt Text

Show parent replies

The post below is a reply to another user


my real take upon seeing this tho is that of course that’d be cool, i do like all the lwma heroic attempts at reinterpretation. there is no shortage of intellectually lazy marxist analysis and my perception is that your crowd exercises much more care in specificity by and large
of course i also think they miss the broader laws of motion that specificity is embedded within, but at least there’s meaningful engagement and it doesn’t make me nauseous (just irked)
what ā€œirkedā€ looks like:
discord diary 1/21/2023
live posting my reaction to https://www.mutualismcoop.com/contemporary-mutualist-text/critique-of-critique-of-the-gotha-programme

look im not defending marx at every point here
but the args ur making against are just horrendous
market anarchists are so dumb waaaa i was about to say idk maybe this person is just dumb and i need to read carson and then they quote carson

"And fairness and unfairness will continue to exist, although concealed (along with the law of value) behind a "collective" planning process. Either the labor entailed in producing the goods consumed by a worker will equal the labor he expends in production, or they will not. If not, somebody is being exploited. The law of value is not simply a description of commodity exchange in a market society; it is a fundamental ethical principle." (Carson)
šŸ’€

kill me bro
its not even wrong
wrong is 10k light years in the other direction, you missed the exit ramp a while ago they just keep using words
that have so so so so so so so so much meaning hidden within them
it really lived rent free
willow 8/29/24, 07:58
me talking to jonas that one time
Xenocat ! @Xenocai • 14h
Had an "anarchist" tell me class analysis is wrong because everyones relation to the MOP is "unique"