willow: "i meant to clarify last night but got distracted, i more meant to ask why the god would be unjust/evil tho it makes sense that if you have an independent notion of justice/moral-whatever that leaving evil unpunished or treating it as equal with goodness would be unjust itself"

Alt Text

Show parent replies

The post below is a reply to another user

i meant to clarify last night but got distracted, i more meant to ask why the god would be unjust/evil tho it makes sense that if you have an independent notion of justice/moral-whatever that leaving evil unpunished or treating it as equal with goodness would be unjust itself

December 17, 2024 at 8:37 AM

willowDec 17, 2024

euthyphro says hi but i don’t think it’s that big of an issue to say something similar to “the god i believe in would judge that state of affairs to be unjust” and call it a day

willowDec 17, 2024

i’d probably be more concerned with that response if the textual evidence for the position didn’t seem so weak