yeah i maybe need to stop using such brute shorthand to describe things (“selfish”)
this passage is kinda v uncompelling to me tho, yay on the anti-liberalism, nay on the christian ethics
sure but wouldn’t that be like kinda scuffed? like do you think it’s like an actual possibility for god actions to deviate from the good? or is it more like in this hypothetical it would be unjust, and that’s all the more reason to reject the universalist reading because that’s impossible
sure but like in this alt universe of universalist god that we’re saying is unjust, if Good and god are one and the same, by what yard stick could you measure god to be unjust?
i meant to clarify last night but got distracted, i more meant to ask why the god would be unjust/evil
tho it makes sense that if you have an independent notion of justice/moral-whatever that leaving evil unpunished or treating it as equal with goodness would be unjust itself
euthyphro says hi but i don’t think it’s that big of an issue to say something similar to “the god i believe in would judge that state of affairs to be unjust” and call it a day